Would You Rather? Round 2
Author: Mike Schmieder
Date: 9 July 2023
Round 2 SF Dynasty Edition
In this series we’re going to go round by round and look at players whose dynasty ADP is in a similar range and I’ll make the case for who I’m taking and why. I will be using a super flex full ppr format as those are quickly becoming the most common setups in new startups.
*I will be using fantasy pros dynasty ECR (expert consensus rankings), which can be found here: https://www.fantasypros.com/nfl/rankings/dynasty-overall.php
Round 1: 11-29 ADP / ECR (7.9.23)
Let’s say you are picking from the 6th spot, in a Super Flex, here are the 4 guys I am considering in the second round. Per the ECR we have a lot of good players to pick from.
Here are the 4 players that I would be targeting:


Jaylen Waddle - Finishing as the WR 8 in 2022 provided a huge boost to his value, showing he could get his job done at a high level even with Tyreek Hill as his running mate. I think Waddle could even see an uptick in targets in 2023 as Mike Geisicki bolted for the Patriots in the off season. One of the questions and things to monitor is who will be the Dolphins WR 3 this year. Waddle is primed for a big season and has immense dynasty value, especially if Tua can stay healthy.
Amon Ra St. Brown - The Sun god is one of my guys in 2023, I am trying to get every possible share that I can in every format. He was such a steal in startups last year and has solidified himself as a dynasty WR1 for the foreseeable future. He can win in all sorts of different ways but crushes volume with slot targets. I think that Jameson Williams coming back after his suspension will help stretch the field for ARSB to get even more underneath.
Justin Fields - Fields had quite an interesting season last year and he hasn't shown the accuracy in the NFL that he showed on the college level yet. Hopefully in the next year or so he can develop into the Bears first 4,000 yard passer in franchise history (nuts right?). Coming off a rough rookie season, he flipped the switch in week 5 and finished as the QB 7. From weeks 5-18 he was the QB 3, up with the likes of Hurts, Allen and Mahomes. Honestly I'm surprised ECR has him in this range he will likely go higher in your league but if he's there in the middle of the 2nd, take him.
Garrett Wilson - Wilson has risen a ton in ADP in the off season and especially due to the Jet's QB upgrade. Wilson was a really good prospect coming out of OSU and proved his profile was no fluke with sub par QB play in his first year.
At this spot in the draft, I think it really depends on what you did in round 1. If you didn't take a QB, you almost have to take Justin Fields in a super flex. From what I have seen in dynasty startups this off season, Fields has gone before 2.06. With his rushing ability he becomes a very valuable fantasy asset. I would likely go with Fields if he was still on the board in the mid 2nd round. If Fields wasn't left, that is where I think it gets really interesting. You could take Dak Prescott or you could go lock in a dynasty WR 1. The decision between Waddle, The Sun god and Wilson is a fascinating one. All are expected to have big seasons in 2023 and beyond. I think right now for me I'd lean Wilson, but it is super close. I'm getting as much of those 3 guys as I possibly can. Amon Ra was one of my favorite off season targets and I am drafting him all over the place in redraft this year.
Who would you rather? Let me know in the poll:
At 2.06 in a SF Dynasty Startup who are you taking?
Jaylen Waddle
Amon Ra St. Brown
Justin Fields
Garrett Wilson
About the Author
Meet Mike, the ultimate NFL fan and a 20-year veteran of the fantasy football game! He's a drafting ninja and a dynasty mastermind with a knack for building deep teams. When it comes to fantasy football, Mike's the guy you call for advice - he's always happy to lend a hand to his pals, family, and even random Twitter folks who need help with their drafts. A few years ago, Mike started making his own rankings and now he's ready to take the plunge into the world of fantasy football writing. Get ready to follow Mike's thoughts as he shares his top tips and tricks for dominating the fantasy football world!






Comments